By Hannah Wallace
Last year’s hurricane season wreaked havoc on Siesta Key and the Sarasota-Bradenton community. Nine months later, recovery is ongoing and hard-won, and many residents have ramped up their demands for authorities to better protect them and their property from natural disasters in the future.
Just across Roberts Bay from south Siesta Cove Drive, a stone’s throw from St. Boniface Episcopal Church on Midnight Pass Road, the mouth of Phillippi Creek marks the origin of arguably the most significant ongoing infrastructure initiative in Sarasota. Record rainfall last year caused catastrophic flooding throughout neighborhoods along the creek, including Pinecraft and South Gate. In addition to the physical damage, those flood waters collected and redistributed harmful bacteria and chemicals, a process that happens (albeit to a lesser extent) during almost every rainfall.
As hurricane season begins again, homeowners and residents anxiously wait for stormwater management projects—most notably dredging of the sediment-filled creek—to move their way through the government before becoming a reality. In a race against time and Mother Nature, the process has been painfully slow.
At just over 7 miles, stretching back east of I-75, Phillippi Creek and its various tributaries are responsible for draining a whopping 57 square miles of Sarasota County—by far the county’s largest watershed and home to nearly half a million people. Though at one point a natural stream, the creek has been dredged and altered for agricultural and residential projects for more than 100 years. And its contaminated status goes back almost as far.
“It’s been impaired forever,” said Dr. Abbey Tyrna, executive director of the Suncoast Waterkeepers and a resident of South Gate. Historical records note that one of the earliest declarations of the creek as “impaired” was in 1931 due to E. coli, and similar findings have been made throughout its history. Despite large-scale efforts, most notably a septic system replacement program that began in 2001, Phillippi Creek still harbors unhealthy levels of fecal bacteria, occasionally punctuated by spikes of harmful algae blooms caused by nitrogen runoff.
“The creek is not safe,” said Tyrna.
Due to the creek’s current physical condition, a lot of that unhealthy water can’t go anywhere. Phillippi Creek was last dredged in 2002. Since then, silt and sediment have steadily accumulated, creating sandbars and shallow spots that have rendered the much of waterway unnavigable, even for kayaks and small boats as well as marine creatures.
Tyrna anecdotally observed that it seems to have gotten worse in the last five years.
“My neighbor’s son had a johnboat that he used to take out, and now he can’t because it’s so silted in,” she said. “In 2020 we had a manatee stuck on the creek. The silt is creating barriers.”
Those barriers are what dredging proponents hope to remedy. A deeper creek would allow more water to drain faster into Roberts Bay instead of overflowing banks and flooding homes.
Practically speaking, dredging Phillippi Creek is straightforward, if cumbersome, according to Spencer Anderson, director of the Sarasota County Public Works Department. “Typically, this will most likely look like an excavator, or backhoe, on a barge that is scooping sediment out of the waterway and into another barge with a roll-off dumpster on it,” he explained. The sediment would then be taken to an area to dry out before most likely being transferred to a landfill.
Like the water itself, the sediment contains contaminants; in some places, there are hidden “reservoirs” of contaminants in the silt that, once established, actually contributed even more bacteria in the water. Removing them may help improve water quality. But, Tyrna pointed out, there is an “ecological tradeoff” in removing the contaminated sediment. “You’re also removing aquatic life, macroinvertebrates, things that people don’t really appreciate, but they’re also indicators of water quality and creek health. They’re also going to remove a lot of the plants in the creek that residents tend to not to like but are super important to the whole ecological circle of life. They will come back, but when there’s such a disturbance, we don’t know what’s going to come back. It could be invasive species.”
Even just disturbing the silt can create “negative impacts” downstream, she added. “When you dredge it just creates sediment movement. It might migrate south downstream, it could end up smothering oyster beds, smothering seagrass beds.”
Those rich habitats are in the higher-salinity waters nearest to eastern Siesta Key, and the negative impacts may spread even farther out. A University of Miami study discovered that dredging projects can create long-distance migration of sediment, smothering coral “a long way away” from the work sites, said Tyrna, who nevertheless acknowledges the necessity of dredging ASAP to mitigate flooding. “It is going to be done on an emergency timeline, so there will be some acute effects [on habitats], but hopefully not in the long-term.”
The bureaucratic path to dredging has been equally murky.
One dredging project, which was approved by the Sarasota County Commission after Hurricane Ian in 2022, is still awaiting permitting from the Army Corps of Engineers. That project will be funded by the West Coast Inland Navigation District (WCIND), a multi-county taxing body, and will target the mouth of Phillippi Creek up to U.S. 41/South Tamiami Trail. Because the WCIND expressly funds projects for public waterways, other parts of the creek did not, at the time, qualify for those funds.
After the 2024 hurricane season, Sarasota was eligible for “expedited permitting” from the Army Corps of Engineers for projects directly addressing issues caused by last year’s storms. (The 2022 project, still awaiting a permit, did not qualify for expedited status as it was linked to a previous storm and to the 20-year lack of dredging.)
The county has developed a two-part dredging plan, according to Anderson. Phase one of that project, which would target about a dozen high spots in the creek, is currently under expedited permit consideration by the Army Corps. (There was no decision as of press time, though Anderson believed that a response was potentially imminent.) Phase two of that project would be a “very thorough dredge from U.S. to Beneva,” he said. “But we’re trying to knock the high spots out [first] to be sure we have as much conveyance as we can.”
To fund both phases, the Sarasota County Commission has requested that a larger portion of Phillippi Creek be designated a public waterway by the WCIND, so that the creek up to the Pinecraft Park would qualify for the district’s funding. (That designation was not yet been adopted by the WCIND as of press time.) On April 25, the county also submitted a request to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) to allocate $75 million of a $201.5 million federal disaster grant for maintenance of major waterways, starting with Phillippi Creek. (HUD officials have 45 days from submission to respond; they had not as of press time.)
The uptick in Phillippi Creek activity is a positive sign for many residents who suffered flood damage, though grumbles remain that action wasn’t taken sooner.
Still, the current solutions are hardly clear-cut.
“We were first advocating for an ecological lens in this dredging to reduce unintended consequences,” said Suncoast Waterkeepers’ Tyrna. “But after hearing resident after resident talk about flooding issues, it was clear that a faster approach must be made, to be sure that people along the creek are not flooding again.”
She added, “It’s important that we advocate a long-term plan that’s attached to this dredging project. Otherwise, we will just see this sediment build up again, and we’ll be here again in 10 to 20 years.”
Tyrna points out that some of the issues with silt buildup stem from neighborhoods like her own South Gate, where sandy topsoil makes it hard for grass to grow. And without nearby stormwater treatment systems, the sand creates immediate problems. “When you can’t lock down soil with root systems, it all moves along our streets and canals and into the creek,” she said. (Likewise, pet waste in that runoff also contributes to the creek’s bacteria levels.)
And sand isn’t the only problem. Anderson adds that flooding events can be exacerbated when stormwater picks up debris from yards and subsequently creates waterway blockages. “We’ve been trying to focus on making sure people are not just preparing their homes and their plans but also their properties,” he explained. “After the storms, we redo our beautiful landscaping, but all that mulch, lawn chairs, lawn ornaments, things from your workshop in your yard—all that flotsam and jetsam gets washed downstream. Just tighten things up so it doesn’t get picked up.”
As they slowly move into view, dredging projects promise some semblance of relief for many residents of Sarasota County. But in the end, while county officials don’t like to speculate, Anderson admits that even effective flooding mitigation won’t stem the tide entirely—especially in the occurrence of another record-breaking rainfall.
“It’s Florida, it rains, it’s flat, and there’s floodplains,” he said. “I’ve heard it said, ‘If you live in a place where it rains in Florida, you should have flood insurance.’”





