Capt. Jim Klopfer’s Siesta Key Fishing Report

Author: Share:

   September is the month that redfish begin schooling up in Sarasota.   The expansive shallow flats in Sarasota Bay are traditionally the most productive areas to fish.  A low, incoming tide in the morning is preferred, allowing anglers to see the large schools of reds.  As the tide rises, the fish will work up from the edges of flats and holes onto the grass to feed.  Locating the fish can be difficult under flood tide conditions; there is just too much water up on the flat to effectively sight fish.

   Speckled trout fishing has been rebounding this year and this should continue in September.  Deeper flats will produce more fish, while the larger specimens may be found in shallow water.  A topwater or shallow diving plug worked over bars at first light is a deadly technique for fooling gator trout.  Anglers fishing the deep grass will catch a variety of species this month including bluefish, Spanish mackerel, mangrove snapper, pompano, gag grouper, and ladyfish.  Both live bait and artificial lures will catch plenty of fish.  A Bass Assassin grub on a ¼ ounce jig head is a great choice for anglers who enjoy casting artificial lures.  Olive (08) X-Raps and other plugs are also effective along with gold and silver spoons.  A live shrimp under a popping cork is a time-proven technique for catching “specks” on the West Coast of Florida.

   Snook will migrate from the beaches back into the bays.  Both passes will be great spots to fish, especially on afternoon outgoing tides.  The bars and mangrove shorelines along Siesta Key are prime spots as the fish move towards their fall feeding areas.  Artificial baits will allow anglers to cover more water, while a well full of pilchards practically guarantees success.  Redfish, large speckled trout, jack crevelle, and mangrove snapper may also be encountered while pursuing the mighty snook.  Lighted docks and bridges are snook magnets and will provide great action for anglers looking to catch fish and escape the summer sun.  Live and artificial shrimp free lined in the tide are deadly, as are small white flies.

Surf fishing off the Siesta Key beaches should be good for snook, ladyfish, Spanish mackerel, pompano, and other species. Point of Rocks is the best spot as there is a lot of fish-holding structure, but any stretch of beach is likely to produce. Live bait such as shrimp and small bait fish works great. A #1 live bait hook with a short piece of leader and a split shot is the preferred rig. Spoons, plugs, and jigs are also effective baits in the surf.

   The rocks and bridges in Big Pass will be excellent spots to target mangrove snapper this month.  These tasty saltwater panfish will be migrating out of the bay and into the Gulf of Mexico.  Slack tides are the best times to drop a live shrimp or bait fish along the structure.  Don’t be surprised if a big snook intercepts a bait meant for a mang!

Visit his website at

Gulf Coast Fishery

Reel Tight Fishing Charters
941-444-9749 /

Growing up on the West Coast of Florida (Sarasota, Siesta Key) and fishing since I can remember, I have always been fond of Snook. The common Snook (Centropomus Undecimalis) thrive in our waters and are found as far West as Texas and as far South as Costa Rica. There are many different types of Snook but the common snook is prevalent to and from Naples and Tampa. I was called the other day to help out a professional fishing team in Grand Isle, Louisiana. They primarily fish for large pelagic species like Blue Marlin and Yellowfin Tuna, but today’s trip was a nearshore trip 20 miles out to the oil rigs. Mangrove Snappers were our target species and a successful week of catching them grew our confidence in placing for the CCA Legislators Tournament. The only hitch was we had a boat load of kids! These Mangrove Snappers are no joke, especially with oil rigs that have tower legs from top to bottom in 90-100 ft. of water, and are a challenge for any skill level of angler.

We started the day around 6:30 a.m. and had the boat loaded up and ready to go. Our junior anglers arrived with their dads. We had a few representatives from the Louisiana government, so we had everything tight, right and ready to go! We bolted offshore in our 58’ Jarret Bay. Jarret Bay is a custom boat builder out of North Carolina. Her name is the “Whoo Dat”, she is named after the New Orleans Saints football team. The owner is a huge fan, just as are most cajuns in this area. We started out fishing some baits on the surface and hooked up immediately. I know it sounds a little crazy to catch a snapper (mostly a bottom dwelling fish),but here on the oil rigs you have structure from top to bottom and the fish find it very appetizing as the small bait fish use the tower legs as a food source and for protection. We caught a few nice fish and then the Sharks moved in. We moved to another oil rig and knew it was going to be a better round of catching. We dropped some chum and the water lit up with nice Snappers, Sharks and a few Cobia! We caught a big Mangrove Snapper and while we finished putting that fish in the box our next little angler had a drag screamer. I looked over and saw a nice fish racing along the surface. “It’s a Cobia, it’s a Cobia”, Capt. Chris yelled. I could tell by the pitch in his voice it was a good fish and we needed that species for the tournament. After a ten minute fight and a few circles around the boat we landed the fish and cheered!! We went back to fishing and caught a few more Mangroves Snapper.

Time for weigh in. Now most big sport fish boats cruise at 24-28 knots. The “Whoo Dat” is a custom made boat designed for speed and rough water. Being that it was slick calm we were able to cruise at 32 knots and made it back to the dock with plenty of time to spare. Our junior anglers were beyond excited as they watched their names go up on the leader board. 1st place Mangrove Snapper as well as the 3rd place Mangrove Snapper! We also had the 3rd place Cobia! Big smiles for everybody and some beautiful trophies for the kids and a few cheers and chuckles for the adults. The CCA in Louisiana is made up of government and state officials. Their desire to sustain the fishery is amazing. They all are fishermen and fisherwomen. They all have their kids fully involved in the conservation side of fishing. They teach and preach how important it is to let the little ones go and limit what you take home. I only hope that as a charter boat company owner that I can help show our state officials how crucial our fishery is to us and how many people’s lives depend on it. Sarasota has some of the most beautiful waters, yet we find ourselves struggling to keep fish alive. From fertilizer running off into the bay to waste management facilities, we have to do a better job as humans. If we don’t start to work on the management of our eco system our kids and their children will never get to experience the type of fishing we have. I know in my 37 years on this earth, I have seen drastic change, and not for the better.

To sustain our fishery at home we will need to do a better job to reduce our human footprint. Our captains need to keep an eye out for trash floating in the water and make sure to keep their trash in the boat. Little things can go a long way, and during turtle nesting season it is especially important to keep single use plastics out of the water.

Be safe on the water, catch some fish and if you can, pick up a piece of garbage that you see. I promise you’ll feel better about yourself!

Siesta Sand
Author: Siesta Sand

Previous Article


Next Article

The Highs and Lows­­­­­ of Properties Sold on Siesta Key