By Ned Steele
As Halloween approaches, the question must be asked… is Siesta Key haunted?
Let’s start with this: How could any place a stone’s throw from Stephen King’s house not be haunted?
There are tales about the famed novelist’s Casey Key property, and there are eerie legends about ancient Native warriors, Spanish conquistadors, and settlers. We’ll get to them. But first let’s consider the experience of Sheila Monaghan, born and raised on Siesta Key.
Back in the mid-1980s, Monaghan tragically lost her brother Tommy in Texas to a drunk driver. Two years later, lying in bed the night before her Siesta Key wedding, Monaghan suddenly became aware of a presence.
A barefoot man – her brother – dressed in white denim stepped out of a closet and started talking.
“He told me he couldn’t go to the wedding because he wasn’t allowed inside the church,” Monaghan recalled. “But he said I shouldn’t worry – everything was going to be alright.”
Tommy’s wife came to the wedding and brought a photo of Tommy. He was wearing the exact same outfit Monaghan had seen in the vision in her bedroom.
For some time, Monaghan would wonder what her brother meant when he told her not to worry. Sadly, she found out. The marriage did not go well. But – true to Tommy’s word – things ultimately were fine in her life.
The experience wasn’t Monaghan’s only encounter with the other side.
As a teenager, she often slept over at the house of a friend whose stepfather Bob had committed suicide in that house a few years earlier.
One hot, still August night, in the friend’s old non-airconditioned home near the canal, Monaghan suddenly sat bolt upright in her bed. There was a strong rustling of cool air, coming through the sliding doors from the room where the suicide had occurred.
Shaken, she recounted the event to her friend the next morning who said, “Oh don’t worry. It was Bob walking through the house checking on everyone.”
“She was very calm about it,” Monaghan recounted. “The family felt it was not unusual for Bob to be walking around.”
Many years later, the friend’s family sold the home. A year to the day later, it mysteriously burned to the ground.
Monaghan is now the office manager of Sarasota Suncoast Tours on the mainland, (which perhaps not coincidentally) runs tours of haunted Sarasota. Her experiences are modern-day echoes of legends and lore about Siesta Key and environs going back hundreds of years.
Sarasota and Siesta Key, with their unparalleled quartz beach, have long been felt to have special mystical properties and other-worldly energy vortexes. Legends accompany that belief. Centuries ago, the conquistador Hernando de Soto explored these shores. One tale from the 1906 book “Legend of Sara de Soto” tells the tragic tale of his daughter.
As it is told, she falls into a passionate, forbidden love affair with an Indian chief, Chichi Okobee. After the Spanish conquer the Indians, she becomes gravely ill and dies. Her father acquiesces to Chichi Okobee’s request to bury her at sea in Sarasota Bay.
A fleet of warriors paddles out to perform the ritual, and then the chief commands his warriors to sink their canoes and die of drowning in the same waters – so he and they can protect his beloved Sara de Soto eternally.
And that, legend has it, helps explain why Sarasota and Siesta Key have been spared a direct hurricane hit for so many years: the ancient warriors are protecting not just Sara but our community from harmful forces. The whitecaps that rise in the Gulf when a storm approaches? That’s Chichi Okobee and his braves fighting off the danger.
Right across the bay from the key is Spanish Point. Believers of mystical goings-on have long linked the area to the spirits of Native peoples, Spanish settlers, and even the instrumental 20th century figure Bertha Palmer.
Archaeological ruins going back 3,000 years, including an ancient burial ground, sit on Spanish Point. Followers of the paranormal have long experienced heightened, mysterious happenings there. They attribute some to the ancients, but they also tell of sighting European settlers’ spirits wandering amid the gumbo limbo trees. In particular, they report hearing the dim ringing of church bells in the dead of night at Mary’s Chapel, named for a young woman who passed away nearby in 1892.
As if that isn’t enough, the ghost of Bertha Palmer, the dominant figure who developed much of modern Sarasota, is reported to be seen patrolling the grounds of her historic Spanish Point estate garden to this day.
And then there’s the Casey Key home of Stephen King. It’s hidden from passerby view, but there are stories.
According to the website stephenkingly.net, “(King’s) work is a testament to the powerful ways in which places can shape and inspire creative expression.” The novel “Bag of Bones” is cited. Key scenes are set around Casey Key.
Of more note are the tales about the property itself. Spook-followers say there’s a tree on the King property that’s haunted by the ghosts of the Seminoles who were driven from the area. According to legend, misfortune will befall anyone who touches it.
Then there are the local residents who report seeing mysterious figures and inexplicable lights coming from the house and property, even when no one is – supposedly – at home.
And finally, there’s this: King is one of the most prolific authors ever – 65 novels and 200 short stories. Literary circles have long marveled at his productivity, and wondered how it’s humanly possible. All those indelible characters and fantastical plot lines he conjures. Where do they come from?
Creative types often say their best inspirations arrive unbidden, just popping into their brain. From where? The air that wafts over the Gulf Coast around Siesta Key?
If so…. What’s in that air?





