I am writing to bring urgent attention to a growing issue on Siesta Key that affects not just one neighborhood—but the entire character of our bayfront community and the health of Little Sarasota Bay.

A neighbor on Midnight Pass Road has installed a large canvas covering over his boat, which significantly obstructs the view of the bay. While this may sound like a simple neighbor dispute, it has far broader consequences for Sarasota County. If approved, this boat covering could set a precedent that allows other homeowners to do the same—resulting in widespread visual blight and diminished waterfront aesthetics throughout the region.

The county has previously informed the homeowner that the structure is not permitted, but he has since retained legal counsel and is challenging the decision before a local review committee. We were told that neighbors within a 500-foot radius will be notified of the hearing date. However, this is not just a local issue—it impacts every resident and visitor who enjoys the natural beauty of Sarasota Bay.

Allowing these structures would:

• Obstruct iconic views of the bay, a key feature that defines the value and identity of Siesta Key;
• Devalue surrounding properties, according to local real estate professionals, including my neighbor who is a licensed agent;
• Encourage visual clutter and overdevelopment along a fragile and highly visible waterfront corridor;
• Set a dangerous precedent that may be difficult to reverse.

Can you imagine an entire stretch of bayfront properties lined with canvas-covered boats? It would drastically change the landscape and charm that attracts residents, visitors, and homebuyers to our area.

I urge you to investigate and help bring broader public attention to this matter before it quietly sets a new, damaging precedent. I am happy to provide further documentation, including communications from county officials, photographs of the obstruction, and expert opinions from real estate professionals who understand the impact on property values.

Please feel free to contact me at your convenience. Thank you for your time and for helping protect the beauty and character of Sarasota Bay.

Karen Martellucci