What’s next for the Siesta Key real estate market?
Aerial view of the Siesta Key beach with the most white and clean sand, Florida.

What’s next for the Siesta Key real estate market?

Articles you may have missed

Siesta Sand Legacy Articles Archives

By Ned Steele

Cautious optimism and ‘wait-and-see’ sum up the attitude of real estate industry professionals after Hurricanes Helene and Milton swept through Siesta Key.

“We are still Siesta Key, which will always be one of the world’s beautiful beaches. That’s not going away,” said Wendy Kesslak, a realtor at RE/MAX Alliance Group.

The real estate recovery will take varied forms, brokers interviewed for this article predicted. Some owners will rebuild, some will tear down and build anew to code, some will tear down and sell for lot value. Some will leave Siesta Key forever, and some will stay to eventually reap handsome rewards.

The course a homeowner takes will depend on numerous individual factors including a property’s extent of damage, cost of renovating, FEMA regulations, insurance status, and the personal needs and preferences of the owner.

One thing seems likely: after a period of time Siesta Key will emerge with newer, more resilient, sturdier homes – probably carrying higher price tags.

“Out of the ashes will rise a much newer Siesta Key – but it will take time,” Kesslak said.

A 2023 study in the Journal of Environmental Economics and Management examined the effect on property values of hurricanes across Florida over 16 years. It concluded that home prices temporarily rise, and wealthier buyers move in after a hurricane.

One reason prices may move up, at least in the short term, is reduced supply. With many houses off the market, potential buyers – and brokers believe these will still exist in ample numbers – will have fewer options, leading to higher prices for habitable houses.

Joe Kesslak, Wendy’s husband and also a RE/MAX broker, said, “We believe it’s going to be a very strong market. Buyers who have been watching are going to swoop in.”

While many homeowners who sustained serious losses are still in shock and weighing their next move, investors are circling. “We Buy Homes” signs have popped up along Siesta Key’s roads, and residents report receiving phone calls from professional investors.

Judie Berger, a realtor at Premier Sotheby’s International Realty, said about 50 of her clients have reached out to her since the two storms and “only one or two want to sell.” The rest, she said, were seeking advice as to how to proceed with their damaged homes. Many are exploring options for elevating their homes to meet the current code requirements.

“There is hope out there,” she said. “Siesta Key is strong and it’s desirable. There will be a paradigm shift – things will change.”

While heavily damaged homes have obviously lost value, she believes intact or repaired homes will hold or increase their value. “Teardowns,” she added, “will be for lot value.”

Berger urged homeowners uncertain of their next move to avoid making quick decisions under duress. Renovating may be the best scenario for many, depending on how much damage was done. (FEMA regulations will block many homeowners from rebuilding if the cost of doing so exceeds 50% of the home’s value.) For some, she added, moving from a one-family home to a condo may be the solution.

The condo market is even more uncertain than that of the one-family home market. Concerns about soaring insurance costs and HOA dues may depress sales and prices. “Or not”, said Berger: “Maybe more people will want to move from one family homes into condos.”

As for tourist rentals, supply and demand may determine the market’s health as the season approaches. Mike Holderness, owner of Beachside Management, estimated that 20% of the Key’s rentals are damaged, reducing supply to 80%. Many properties are renovating and refurbishing, he said, driving the market in a positive direction when they go back online: “The quality on Siesta Key will be better than it’s been in 40 years,” he predicted. “Everyone is getting new furniture and new landscaping.”

Real estate professionals are eternal optimists, and no one knows what the future will bring. It’s too soon to take a serious appraisal of where the market is or where it’s going. But some realities remain true, and they cut both ways.

Hurricanes can and will happen, unpredictably and occasionally devastatingly. But, as Judie Berger observed, “Once the debris is cleaned up and it gets cold up north, people will see the beauty of Siesta Key again.”

You May Also Like